Monday, October 20, 2025

Brad's big beautiful boasts

For better or worse, the art of politics involves exaggeration and hyperbole – stretching the truth without crossing the line into outright lies.

In July, Congressman Brad Finstad sent a spiffy mailing to constituents claiming credit for the “One Big Beautiful Bill” and boasting about all he’d done for Minnesota farmers by voting for the OBBB.  It was very nice looking and chock full of pretty color photos of Brad, the farmer.

The mailing is a master class in claiming credit and hiding the details.  While I can’t really say it’s all BS from Brad, there sure is a lot of baloney.

  • The “One Big Beautiful Bill” is not an agricultural bill or a farm bill.  It is a wide-ranging budget reconciliation bill.  It was not designed to provide relief to farmers.
  • Brad claims “historic support for voluntary, farmer-friendly conservation programs.”  That’s just a plain old lie.  The “One Big Beautiful Bill” merely repeals and redirects climate-focused funding from previous legislation.
  • Although the “One Big Beautiful Bill” rearranges a few crop insurance and farm safety net programs, those changes are limited to farmers who produce only certain crops or are new to farming.

Brad wants us to just believe whatever he says.  But if Brad would answer his phone or reply to an email, there are some questions I’d like to ask him about the things he’s said about the “One Big Beautiful Bill” and especially some of the details our Congressman … umm … let’s just say “forgot” to mention:

Brad’s Baloney:  The OBBB means “Security for Southern Minnesota Farmers”

What are you talking about Brad?  The “One Big Beautiful Bill” includes only a few provisions related to farming and agriculture.  It is not a farm bill and is not intended to help farmers.  The focus is taxes, healthcare (especially Medicaid), immigration and border security, and other federal programs unrelated to farming and agriculture.

The bottom line is this: the “One Big Beautiful Bill” was not intended to help farmers.  The purpose was to implement President Trump’s second-term agenda and specifically to make his 2017 tax cuts permanent.

Brad’s Baloney:  “Makes the Death Tax exemption permanent and raises the exemption to $15 million, helping farmers and small businesses in MN-01 pass their operations down to the next generation.”

C'mon Brad!  You know full well that there is no such thing as a “Death Tax.”  The truth is the “One Big Beautiful Bill” has eliminated the taxes on estates up to $15,000,000.  And you must know that you're - I'll be polite - exaggerating when you say farmers cannot not “pass their operations down to the next generation.”

The value of farmland varies across the state but let’s assume a value of $7,500 per acre.  The “One Big Beautiful Bill” allows a farm couple to pass nearly 4,000 acres tax free.  How many 4,000 acre family farms are there in Minnesota?

Let's face it.  The fact is, even before the “One Big Beautiful Bill” became law, the average Minnesota farmer could pass their farm tax free.

Brad’s Baloney:  “Enhances crop insurance, including provisions from my legislation, the FARMER Act, to expand access and reduce costs for producers.”

Oh Brad!  I understand you’re proud of your pet legislation.  It’s probably your first time introducing a bill.  But to say the “One Big Beautiful Bill” adopts provisions from your proposed “FARMER Act” is really stretching it, don’t you think?  The “One Big Beautiful Bill” is a tax bill, not a farm bill.  Congress has still not acted on a farm bill.

And “expand access and reduce costs”?  Well, I guess there’s some truth, but only for a very few farmers who are new or produce certain crops.  The fact is the “One Big Beautiful Bill” changes the coverage level and affordability of crop insurance policies for farmers who produce “specialty crops” (certain fruits, vegetables, herbs, and flowers) and offers more affordable crop insurance for beginning farmers during their first ten years of operation.

Brad’s Baloney:  “Strengthens critical risk management tools that farmers depend on” and  “Strengthens safety net programs like ARC and PLC”

Do you really believe the “One Big Beautiful Bill” somehow “strengthens” the safety net?  Or is that something your staff wrote for you?  The “One Big Beautiful Bill” provides $66 billion in spending for some farm safety net programs and modifies the Price Loss Coverage (PLC) and Agriculture Risk Coverage (ARC) farm payment programs by changing the reference prices to increase payments for farmers if market prices remain low.

Brad’s Baloney:  “Increases investments in foreign animal disease prevention and response.”

“Increases”?  The fact is the “One Big Beautiful Bill” mostly extends existing programs that were to expire at the end of 2025.

Brad’s Baloney:  “Invests additional funding in trade promotion programs to keep U.S. agriculture competitive.”

Maybe this is partially true, but you’ve got to wonder.  The “One Big Beautiful Bill” creates a new Supplemental Agricultural Trade Promotion Program with $285 million in funding, but not until FY2027.  It also increases funding for the existing Market Access Program (MAP) and Foreign Market Development (FMD).

And then you've got to wonder: is this enough to offset the economic havoc from the Trump tariffs?

Brad’s Baloney:  “Provides historic support for voluntary, farmer-friendly conservation programs.”

Now you’ve got to admit Brad, this is just plain old BS!  The fact is the “One Big Beautiful Bill” repeals funds for agricultural conservation programs that were originally provided by the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA).  Instead of claiming “historic support,” why don’t you be honest and admit the intention is to repeal the conservation innovations implemented by the Biden administration.

It is true that some funds are redistributed – and a few previously unbudgeted programs are now budgeted – the “One Big Beautiful Bill” reduces and redirects funding away from climate-smart practices and climate-specific goals.  For example, the “One Big Beautiful Bill” repeals IRA funds for EQIP, CSP, ACEP, and RCPP.

Even worse - and this one really pisses me off - the “One Big Beautiful Bill” eliminates the requirement from the IRA that these additional funds be used for climate change-related conservation practices!

“Historic support for conservation programs”?  My ass!

Okay, I’ll stop … for now.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Brad's big beautiful boasts

For better or worse, the art of politics involves exaggeration and hyperbole – stretching the truth without crossing the line into outright ...